News Cyrus Mistry Hits Back At Tata Group With Loads Of Allegations : Fraudulent Transactions, Unethical Ways

Cyrus Mistry Hits Back At Tata Group With Loads Of Allegations : Fraudulent Transactions, Unethical Ways

Ousted as chairman of Tata Sons in a boardroom coup Monday, Cyrus Mistry has hit back, levelling a series of allegations against the Tata Group and predecessor Ratan Tata including those relating to fraudulent transactions, unethical practices and conflict of interest.

Flagging “total lack of corporate governance” in the over $100-billion conglomerate where he says he was reduced to a “lame duck chairman”, Mistry has questioned investment decisions during Ratan Tata’s tenure in several group companies — he has called them “legacy hotspots” — and has warned the board and trustees of a potential $18-billion writedown.

- Advertisement -


- Advertisement -

While the official spokesperson of Tata Sons declined comment on Mistry’s allegations, Abhishek Manu Singhvi, senior advocate advising Tata Sons on the matter, said: “No purpose is going to be served by washing dirty linen in public. To every allegation, severe counter allegations are possible. If an overwhelming majority of the nine wise men and women of the board lost confidence in the chairman, what’s the point of making allegations.”

“The factors which go to making loss of confidence are obviously diverse and serious and include economic, corporate, managerial, moral and ethical issues. But even courts do not tread into the review of such causes. Hence, the press should desist from speculative misadventure,” Singhvi said.

In an email to the board of Tata Sons and trustees of Tata Trusts Tuesday, Mistry said :

I cannot believe that I was removed on grounds of non-performance. I am not sure if the individual board members and trustees truly appreciated the extent of the problems I had inherited. Prior to my appointment, I was assured that I would be given a free hand. The previous Chairman (Ratan Tata) was to step back and be available for guidance and advice as and when needed.

But after his appointment, Mistry said, the Articles of Association were modified, changing the rules of engagement between the trusts, the board of Tata Sons, the chairman and the operating companies.


Mistry hits back: lack of corporate governance, was lame duck chairman :

“Inappropriate interpretation indeed followed and it severely constrained the ability of the group to engineer the necessary turnaround and as feared, the inappropriate implementation created a flux in the decision-making process,” he said.

According to Mistry, the foreign acquisition strategy, with JLR and Tetley being exceptions, had left a large debt overhang. “The European steel business faced potential impairments in excess of $10 billion, only some of which has been taken as of date. Many foreign properties of Indian Hotels and holdings in Orient Hotels have been sold at a loss… Indian hotels, beyond flawed international strategy, had acquired the Searock property at a highly inflated prices and housed in an off balance sheet structure. In the process of unravelling this legacy, Indian Hotels has had to write down nearly its entire networth over the past three years. This impairs its ability to pay dividends,” he said. The telecom business, he said, has been continuously haemorrhaging. “If we were to exit this business via fire sale or shut down, the cost would be $ 4-5 billion. This is in addition to any payout to DoCoMo of at least a billion plus dollars. The original structure of DoCoMo transaction raises several questions about its appropriateness from a commercial or prudential perspective within the then prevailing Indian legal framework,” Mistry alleged.

On the power business, he said Tata Power aggressively bid for the Mundra project based on low-priced Indonesian coal and a change in rules now pose a threat to future capital impairment.


Mistry’s email is critical of Ratan Tata and his Nano car project: “Nano’s product development concept called for a car below Rs one lakh, but the costs were always above this. This product has consistently lost money, peaking at Rs 1,000 crore. As there is no line of sight to profitability for the Nano, any turnaround strategy for the company requires to shut it down. Emotional reasons alone have kept us away from this crucial decision. Another challenge in shutting down Nano is that it would stop the supply of Nano gliders to an entity that makes electric cars and in which Mr Tata has a stake.” On the performance of the portfolio, he said, “if we look at the aggregate data between 2011 and 2015 and limit the analysis largely to the legacy hotspots (Indian Hotels, Tata Motors PV, Tata Steel Europe, Tata Power Mundra and Tata Teleservices), it will show that the capital employed in those companies has risen from Rs 132,000 crore to Rs 196,000 crore (due to operational losses, interest and capex). This figure is close to the networth of the group which is at Rs 174,000 crore. A realistic assessment of the fair value (of) these businesses could potentially result in a writedown over time of about Rs 118,000 crore”.

Tata Capital, had a book that required “significant clean up on account of bad loans to the infrastructure sector.

Attacking Tata’s investment in the airline business, Mistry said: “Early in my tenure, our foray into the aviation sector began when Mr Tata ushered me into his office and handed me a report on Air Asia… and wanted the proposal tabled at the forthcoming Tata Sons board meeting. My pushback was hard but futile… A few months later, I was surprised to be confronted with a similar situation requiring me to execute a fait accompli JV with Singapore Airlines… The passion for the airline sector has led Mr Tata to continue his involvement with the strategy of the two airlines.”


He said “board members and trustees are also aware that in the case of Air Asia, ethical concerns have been raised with respect to certain transactions as well as the overall prevailing culture within the organisation. A recent forensic investigation revealed fraudulent transactions of Rs 22 crore involving non-existent parties in India and Singapore. Executive Trustee, Mr Venkatraman, who is on the board of Air Asia and also a shareholder in the company, considered these transactions as non-material and did not encourage further study. It was only at the insistence of independent directors, one of who immediately submitted his resignation, that the board decided belatedly to file a first information report”.

Now You Can Get the Latest Buzz On Your Phone! Download the PagalParrot Mobile App For Android and IOS

Trending now

Katrina Kaif Playing Cards As A bride: Photo Went Viral On Social Media

Bollywood actress Katrina Kaif has shared photos in which she is seen playing cards as a bride. Also, Katrina looks very happy with this and she is with her team.  Katrina Kaif Playing Cards as a bride In the...

Trailer Of Hacked Is Trending!! Vikram Bhatt’s New Stalker Thriller Starring Hina Khan Will Shake You From Within!

Vikram Bhatt's 'Hacked- There Is No Place To Hide' will release on 7th February, 2020. The film stars Hina Khan, Rohan Shah and Sid Makkar. As of now, the epic trailer of the thriller film is trending on the internet. Public is already shaken and is eagerly...

Florida Cold Weather Leads To Falling Iguana Alert

Falling Iguana Alert: The National Weather Services usually warns people falling rain, snow, and hail. But temperatures went so low in South Florida that this made the forecasters warn residents about falling iguanas on Tuesday. Falling iguanas due to cold weather in South...

Kylie Jenner Puts Her Curvy Figure On Instagram In Grey Bikini As She Relaxes In Miami

Kylie Jenner is currently relaxing in Miami on holiday with daughter Stormi. But, by taking a short break from her baby girl Kylie decided for an impromptu photo shoot. Also, Kylie was wearing a grey strapless bikini top and matching bottoms...

Trending This Week

ISRO’s Humanoid ‘Vyomitra’ Will Go To Space Before Mission Gaganyaan 2022

ISRO has released a video of a humanoid or robot being sent into space before the Gaganyaan mission of 2022. ISRO has...

Kartik Aryan And Sara Ali Khan Reveals Their Plan For Valentine’s Day

The rumors of Kartik Aryan and Sara Ali khan relations are in the air for a long time.

America’s ‘Firefall’ Video Goes Viral, Hits More Than 3 Million Views in Two Days

This Viral Firefall video is made in Yosemite National Park, CaliforniaAccording to officials, this is a simple...

Advocate Indira Jaising Asks Nirbhaya’s Mother to Follow Sonia Gandhi’s Example, Pardon Convicts

Delhi court postponed the date of the execution of the four convicts. Advocate Indira Jaising requested mercy from Nirbhaya's mother with Twitter...

Nora Fatehi Learning Martial Arts To Play The Role of Indian Spy

The sizzling beauty of Bollywood Nora Fatehi is Learning Martial Arts 4 Hours Daily these days. Her movie 'Bhuj: The Pride of...

Jhund First Poster: Amitabh Bachchan Appeared Alone In The First Look Of The Film

The first poster of Amitabh Bachchan's upcoming film Jhund has been released today. Nagarjuna Manjule, who made super...

Deepika’s Retro look Went Viral In Polka Dot Dress: Have A Look

Deepika Padukone is one of the great and most beautiful Indian actresses. This actress always stays on the top of headlines because...

Fans Waiting For Genelia, ‘The Cutie’ To Return On Screen!

It has been a long time since Genelia D'Souza Deshmukh has separated herself from 'Big Screen'. However, she is highly active on...